Tuesday, November 30, 2010

The DREAM Act; article and letter

The following was submitted today to our local newspaper. The fact that the article comes from clergy of a different faith strengthens its effect. After the article which you may use in any way helpful for this cause, is a "fill-in model" of a letter to senators which I sent out to my clergy friends. Please feel free to share this with other clergy. Tell them to send their letters as faxes, not snail mail or email, and on official church, synagogue, mosque etc stationary. Much of this is inspired by the RAC website on the DREAM Act. We need this to become viral.

Let’s Make Their DREAMS Come True!
Rabbi Fred Guttman and Rev. Mark Sills

Recently, two very bright young women graduated with honors from Greensboro area universities. One received a degree in nursing, the other received a degree in chemical engineering. Both of these young women have talents and skills that are in high demand. These graduates are the kind of young adults that every community wants to attract and keep.
.
Talented, disciplined, and with a keen sense of civic responsibility, they would be a wonderful asset for Greensboro.Unfortunately, neither of these talented women will be able to pursue their career in Greensboro. Even though there are several local employers who want to hire them, neither can work legally anywhere in the United States. These young women were brought to the United States from Mexico when they were just pre-schoolers. They grew up here. This is home to them. Both had outstanding records at local high schools, and they would like nothing more than to contribute their considerable talents to our land. Because they are undocumented immigrants, they cannot do so. These young women will be forced to leave the United States to work in other countries in order to fulfill their personal dreams.

In the next two weeks, the lame duck session of Congress could finally do something to alleviate this injustice. The Congress is due to consider Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors (DREAM) Act. Each year, some 65,000 students who entered America illegally with their parents will graduate from High School. The DREAM Act would give these students a path to citizenship if they attend college or join the military.

There is sound biblical basis for asking for your support of the DREAM Act. Leviticus teaches us, “When strangers sojourn with you in your land, you shall not do them wrong. The strangers who sojourn with you shall be to you as the natives among you, and you shall love them as yourself; for you were strangers in the land of Egypt” [19:33-34].

We are a compassionate country! The idea that we would expel a child who has lived here since he or she was young because of the choices of their parents is nothing short of cruel. For all intents and purposes, this child is an American. It is nothing less than a horrific example of holding a child responsible for the sins of the parent. In addition, we as a country would be deprived of the unique, God-given contributions that this child, a product of our educational system, would be able to give to our country.

These students often live in constant fear of detection by immigration authorities. It is now time for us as a country to give them hope. After all, their only “crime” was being born to parents who came to this country to pursue a better for themselves and their children, just like many of our ancestors.

We see this as a compelling religious and a moral issue. Apparently others in Congress do as well, for the DREAM Act has solid bi-partisan support.

As clergy dedicated to helping our country to become more just and compassionate, we urge the passage of the DREAM Act and call on those who read this to contact their elected representatives in support of this act. The DREAM Act will go a long way towards making legitimate dreams come true for the young people that it is designed to help.

(Rabbi Fred Guttman is rabbi of Temple Emanuel Greensboro and Rev Mark Sills is the Executive Director of FaithAction International House in Greensboro. In 2009, they were co-recipients of the National Conference for Community and Justice (NCCJ) Brotherhood Citation Award, 2009. )

SAMPLE LETTER FOR CLERGY.



Senator Fax: (xxx) xxx-xxxx

Dear Senator ,

As a committed , I encourage you to support the Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors (DREAM) Act (S. 729). This important, bipartisan legislation will allow law-abiding high school students, many of whom have lived in the United States nearly their entire lives but remain undocumented, a chance to go to college or serve in the military.

Each year about 65,000 U.S.–raised students who would qualify for the DREAM Act’s benefits graduate from high school. Even though they were brought to the U.S. years ago as children, they face unique barriers to higher education, are unable to work legally in the U.S., and often live in constant fear of detection by immigration authorities.

There is sound biblical basis for asking for your support of the DREAM Act. Leviticus teaches us, “When strangers sojourn with you in your land, you shall not do them wrong. The strangers who sojourn with you shall be to you as the natives among you, and you shall love them as yourself; for you were strangers in the land of Egypt” [19:33-34].

We are a compassionate country! The idea that we would expel a child who has lived here since he or she was young because of the choices of their parents is nothing short of cruel. For all intents and purposes, this child is an American. It is nothing less than a horrific example of holding a child responsible for the sins of the parent. In addition, we as a country would be deprived of the unique, God-given contributions that this child, a product of our educational system, would be able to give to our country.

These students often live in constant fear of detection by immigration authorities. It is now time for us as a country to give them hope. After all, their only “crime” was being born to parents who came to this country to pursue a better for themselves and their children, just like many of our ancestors.

We see this as a compelling religious and a moral issue. Apparently others in Congress do as well, for the DREAM Act has solid bi-partisan support.

Therefore as a and as a religious person of conscience, I urge you to vote for the DREAM Act

Most Respectfully,

Do not sign the latest JStreet petition.

There are several reasons why in my opinion, people should NOT sign the J Street Petition.

First, these peace talks are at a very sensitive and critical juncture. The agenda for the peace talks and its sequencing is now being discussed between the U.S. and Israel. In order for these talks to resume and succeed, the two governments need to come to an understanding on these sensitive issues in quiet discussions with no outside intervention--even by well-meaning friends of Israel. Pushing the President to push Israel to accept any specific agenda could be counterproductive.

Second and sadly, a public U.S. statement calling for a specific agenda might push Abbas to reject any other agenda that might be agreed between the U.S. and Israel, thus possibly scuttling the resumption of the peace talks.

Third in essence, this is calling for an imposed a solution on Israel. As one who holds dual citizenship and who served in the Israeli army, whose son and other relatives live there and VOTE there, I find this to be particularly disturbing. In essence, this would curtail Israel’s independence. In addition, such an imposed solution would most likely ignore some very real security concerns and needs that Israel has. Of course, this has been part of JStreet’s ideology since its inception. JStreet is a “proscriptive” organization when it comes to the Middle East Peace process. ‘Israel will need to be saved from itself and we in Washington know what is best for Israel. (Israeli democracy be damned!) Of course, if we are wrong it is no big deal to us because we live here in safety and security. Israel on the other hand… Poor Israelis and Jews! They can never catch a break!’

Most Israelis by the way would view such an action by the Obama administration as being very anti Israel.

For this and other reasons, the only way towards any legitimate and long lasting agreement will be though direct negotiations between the two sides.

Finally, the tone of this sounds to me to be quite partisan. The petition begins with the words: “You (President Obama) have inspired me with your commitment to a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.” On its web site, J-Street writes: “We have stood shoulder to shoulder with President Obama as he has repeatedly pushed both sides toward negotiations. Our community taken hundreds of thousands of actions in support of the President's vision of Middle East peace and his active efforts to make it a reality from day one.” I am beginning to think that on Israel, JStreet has become the left wing alternative to Matt Brooks and the Republican Jewish coalition? I certainly believe that it is in the best interest of Israel for our community to be bi partisan.

A claim is often made that JStreet allows for those who are so upset with Israel to become “involved.” Involved in what? I have not seen this. I have not seen JStreet supporters and rabbis working diligently to bring more people to Israel or to encourage more teens and college students to go there. Frankly as I see it, a sad result of JStreet has been to undermine American Jewish support for Israel.

So once again, I urge those of who are JStreet supporters. We all want peace. The language of such resolutions sounds good, the intentions may be well meaning but the actions called for will move the peace process backwards, not forward.

Before you sign on to the latest J Street petition, you might also want to take a look at Rabbi Micky Boyden’s latest on this issue. Micky, who lost a son in Lebanon, lives four miles from Qalqilia (which is near Kfar Saba). He does not live in the West Bank.

Micky writes: "The J Street petition affirms that its supporters have been inspired by President Obama’s commitment to a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. However, the question is not whether J Street has been inspired but rather whether the Palestinians share the same aspirations. And that is an entirely different matter."

For the full item, go to
http://weareforisrael.org/2010/11/30/borders-and-security-first/

Do not sign the latest JStreet petition.

Fred Guttman